Cheltenham Locker Room Assault: Coaches and Players Now Charged

Last updated: July 30, 2026

Find out if you have a case

Free and confidential. No fee unless we win.

Disclaimer: By submitting the form above and checking the consent box, you agree to our conditions and privacy policy and permit Ethen Ostroff Law to contact you via text messages, phone calls (including automated calls). Standard message rates may apply.

Find Out If You Have a Case For FREE Below No Fee Unless We Win

Disclaimer: By submitting the form above and checking the consent box, you agree to our conditions and privacy policy and permit Ethen Ostroff Law to contact you via text messages, phone calls. Standard message rates may apply.


When a child is hurt at school, parents trust that the adults in charge will step in, speak up, and put that child’s safety first. The Cheltenham locker room assault has raised painful questions about what happens when they don’t. Nearly a year after a 15-year-old was attacked by teammates in the Cheltenham High School football locker room, Montgomery County prosecutors have now filed criminal charges against four coaches and six players — including allegations that the coaches learned what happened and encouraged the teen to stay quiet.

If you’re a parent reading this because something happened to your own child, we understand how overwhelming that is. Below is a plain-language look at what has been reported, where the case stands, and what legal options families in Pennsylvania may have.

Cheltenham locker room with football and jerseys, highlighting the Cheltenham locker room assault incident related to student safety and supervision issues.

Criminal Charges Filed: What We Now Know

On July 29, 2026, the Montgomery County District Attorney’s Office announced charges against four Cheltenham High School football coaches and six players in connection with two assaults on a teammate in the school’s locker room.

According to the District Attorney’s Office, the four coaches — former head coach Terence Tolbert (55), associate head coach Darian McFadden (42), assistant coach Benjamin Johnson III (45), and volunteer coach Ralph Burney (60) — were each charged with endangering the welfare of a child and conspiracy. Prosecutors say the coaches were not present for the assaults but became criminally liable because they learned about them and encouraged the victim not to tell his parents.

Two players, Isaiah Simpson and Josiah Peeler, both 18, were charged as adults. According to prosecutors, Simpson faces charges including conspiracy to commit aggravated assault, simple assault, and reckless endangerment for allegedly taking part in the assaults, while Peeler was charged with false swearing for allegedly being untruthful to police. Four other players who were minors at the time were charged as juveniles, and prosecutors declined to release further details about them.

It’s important to note that being charged is not the same as being convicted. Everyone charged is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.

What Happened at Cheltenham High School

According to the family’s attorneys and the Montgomery County District Attorney, a 15-year-old sophomore was assaulted by teammates on two occasions — once in mid-August 2025 and again on September 3, 2025. Prosecutors say that during the attacks, players restrained the teen and used a broomstick to poke at him, and that the assaults were witnessed by nearly 20 students. The family’s lawyers have said teammates tried to sexually assault the teen with a broomstick during both incidents.

At least one of the assaults was recorded on video and circulated among students before being deleted, according to reporting and the family’s attorneys. Investigators initially believed the video showed the September 3 assault, but this spring determined it was recorded in August — which, according to the family’s lawyers, revealed for the first time that the teen had been attacked more than once.

The teen’s mother has said she learned something was wrong only days later, when her son told her he had been “jumped” and was in pain, and that she took him to urgent care and contacted the school. She later learned about the broomstick allegation after an anonymous report was made to Pennsylvania’s Safe2Say hotline.

Concerns About Supervision and Coaching Oversight

A central question in this case is how two assaults could happen in a school locker room — one of them in front of nearly 20 students — without an adult stepping in to stop it or report it promptly.

An outside investigation commissioned by the district faulted inadequate supervision in the locker room, “a failure to prioritize student safety” by coaches and volunteers, and what it described as “a toxic and negative culture” within the football program. Prosecutors allege that, rather than reporting the September assault to the teen’s mother or school administrators, coaches discussed handling the matter within the team — and that three coaches called the teen the night of the second assault and told him not to tell his parents.

District Response: Two Seasons Canceled, Coaches Separated

The Cheltenham School District has taken several steps as the situation has unfolded. It canceled the remainder of the 2025 football season in October 2025, citing hazing allegations, and in May 2026 announced that the upcoming 2026-2027 season would also be canceled.

In April 2026, the district approved separation agreements with two coaches, including former head coach Terence Tolbert. District officials have said that none of the coaches from last season remains affiliated with the district. Superintendent Brian Scriven has also said a Title IX investigation — required when sexual assault or harassment is alleged — is ongoing, though he noted the district received limited cooperation from students.

Where the Case Stands Now

As of late July 2026, the case is at the criminal charging stage. The accused coaches and players have been charged but not convicted, and those cases will move through the Montgomery County court system. The district’s Title IX investigation remains open.

On the civil side, the family has retained attorneys, and according to reporting, the family is considering legal action. No civil lawsuit settlement has been announced. Criminal charges and civil claims are separate: a criminal case is brought by prosecutors to hold individuals accountable under the law, while a civil claim is how an injured person and their family may seek accountability and compensation for the harm they suffered.

Your Rights If Your Child Was Harmed at School

If your child was injured because of another person’s or an institution’s negligence, you may have legal options, and you don’t have to sort them out alone.

Schools and their staff have a duty to provide reasonable supervision and to keep students reasonably safe. When a child is harmed, and there are questions about whether supervision failed, whether warning signs were ignored, or whether required reports were never made, families may be able to pursue a civil claim for negligent supervision or premises liability (a legal way of saying a property owner or operator may be responsible when unsafe conditions or a lack of reasonable safety measures lead to harm). Depending on the facts, other parties may share responsibility as well.

In Pennsylvania, there are important deadlines — called statutes of limitations — that limit how long you have to file a claim, and special rules can apply to minors and to claims involving public entities. Because those rules are complex and the clock can be running, families who have questions often benefit from speaking with an attorney early, even if they are only trying to understand their options.

Every case is different, and no outcome can be promised. But learning where you stand costs nothing.

Ongoing Investigations by Law Enforcement

Local authorities are continuing to look into what happened alongside the school district’s review. The Cheltenham Township Police Department and the Montgomery County District Attorney’s Office have both confirmed active investigations tied to the Cheltenham locker room assault.

These reviews are separate from the school’s process and could lead to further consequences. Officials have said criminal charges related to the assault in the football locker room have not been ruled out.

The district has also noted that student-specific disciplinary matters are still underway, including Title IX reviews. Depending on how those proceedings play out, some students could face discipline or lose eligibility to participate in school athletics going forward.

Cheltenham Locker Room Assault Sparks Concern Across the Community

News of the investigation has hit a nerve in Cheltenham. Parents and community members are questioning whether students were properly protected and how the school handled an assault in football locker room once it came to light. Many are also asking why it took so long for the situation to surface.

For a lot of families, this case has underscored the need for real oversight in school sports. The fact that several students were there and that players recorded the locker room assault has raised uncomfortable questions about accountability, peer pressure, and what students do when they witness something serious happening right in front of them.

Assault in Football Locker Room: The Questions This Incident Raises

A student was assaulted in the football locker room at Cheltenham High, and nearly 20 others were there when it happened. Some players recorded the locker room assault, which has left families and the community asking serious questions.

People want to know:

  • Were students being watched closely enough? 
  • Did coaches and staff take safety seriously? 
  • Were warning signs missed? 
  • How did the school respond after it happened?

The Cheltenham locker room assault shows why schools need clear rules, proper supervision, and a culture that keeps students safe. When those things are missing, serious problems can happen, and it makes clear why schools have to take action.

Frequently Asked Questions

Four Cheltenham High School football coaches and six players have been charged. According to the Montgomery County District Attorney, the coaches — Terence Tolbert, Darian McFadden, Benjamin Johnson III, and Ralph Burney — face charges of endangering the welfare of a child and conspiracy. Two 18-year-old players were charged as adults, and four players who were minors at the time were charged as juveniles. Everyone charged is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

Prosecutors say the coaches became criminally liable because they learned about the assaults and encouraged the teen not to tell his parents, rather than reporting the incident. According to the District Attorney, the coaches allegedly discussed handling the matter within the team instead of notifying the victim’s mother or school administrators. These are allegations, and the coaches have not been convicted.

In many cases, yes — a criminal case and a civil claim are separate. A family may be able to pursue a civil claim if a child was harmed because of negligence, such as inadequate supervision or a failure to report. As of this writing, no civil lawsuit settlement in the Cheltenham case has been announced. Whether a specific family has a claim depends on the facts, so it’s best to speak with an attorney.

Pennsylvania sets deadlines called statutes of limitations, and they can be shorter than people expect — with special rules that can apply to minors and to claims involving public entities like school districts. Because the timeline can vary and the deadline can pass, it’s wise to ask an attorney about your specific situation as early as possible.

No. Consultations at EOL.law are free, and we work on a contingency basis — meaning there are no upfront fees and no fee unless we recover for you. You can reach us anytime to ask questions and understand your options.

EOL.Law Is Following the Story

As the criminal cases move forward and the district’s Title IX review continues, more details may come to light about the Cheltenham locker room assault and its impact on the students and families involved. Our hearts are with the young person at the center of this and with every family watching it unfold.

Find out if you have a case — no cost, no obligation. Tell us what happened and we’ll help you understand your options.

His career began in public service as a Surveillance Officer in Maricopa County, where he gained firsthand experience in high-stakes decision-making and developed a deep sense of discipline and accountability. He later served as Chief Operating Officer of a fast-growing law firm, driving efficiency, revenue growth, and team development. Today, Ryan focuses on helping law firms reach their full potential by aligning people, processes, and long-term vision. A strategic thinker and empowering leader, Ryan is passionate about developing others and guiding organizations through meaningful, lasting growth.

Success

We received your information. We’ll be in touch soon.

Ethen Ostroff Law, PLLC Privacy Policy

Effective Date: 10/15/2026

Ethen Ostroff Law, PLLC (“EOL,” “we,” “us,” or “our”) respects your privacy. If you are reaching out to us after an injury, we know you may be sharing personal details during a hard time. This Privacy Policy explains what information we collect when you visit ethenostrofflaw.com (the “Site”), how we use it, who we share it with, and the choices you have.

This Privacy Policy works together with our Terms of Use. By using the Site, you agree to the practices described here. If you do not agree, please do not use the Site.

1. A note about confidentiality

Visiting the Site, submitting a form, chatting with us online, or sending us an email does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship begins only when you and EOL sign a written Retainer Agreement. Until then, information you send us is not protected by attorney-client privilege and is not considered confidential. Please do not send sensitive details about your matter until we have spoken with you.

2. Information you give us

When you request a free consultation, fill out a form, use our live chat, call, text, or email us, you may give us:

  • Your name, phone number, email address, and mailing address
  • The state where you live or where your injury happened
  • Details about your injury, accident, employer, or legal matter
  • Anything else you choose to include in a message or chat

3. Information collected automatically

When you visit the Site, we and the third-party tools described in section 8 may automatically collect:

  • Your IP address and general location
  • Browser type, device type, and operating system
  • Pages you visit, how long you stay, and the page or ad that referred you
  • Actions you take, such as clicking a button or submitting a form
  • Cookie IDs and similar identifiers

4. How we use your information

  • To respond to you and evaluate whether we may be able to help with your matter
  • To contact you by phone, text, or email about your inquiry or case
  • To understand how people use the Site and improve it
  • To measure how well our advertising performs
  • To show our ads to people who have visited the Site and to reach new people who may need our help
  • To protect the Site from spam and abuse
  • To comply with legal and ethical obligations

5. How we share your information

We may share your information with:

  • Service providers who help us run the Site, our chat tools, our phone and text systems, and our case intake process. They may use your information only to provide services to us.
  • Advertising and analytics partners through the cookies and pixels described in section 8.
  • Other law firms and attorneys. If your matter is outside our practice or the states we serve, we may refer you to another firm. EOL may also refer or sell inquiries that come through our marketing, including certain campaigns run with third-party marketing companies.
  • Legal and safety recipients when required by law, court order, or professional rules, or to protect our rights or the safety of others.
  • A successor in connection with a merger, sale, or transfer of our practice, where permitted by professional rules.

6. Text messages

If you opt in to text messages, you may receive messages about your inquiry or case. Message frequency varies, and message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP at any time to opt out, or HELP for help. Mobile phone numbers and text message opt-in consent will not be shared with third parties or affiliates for their own marketing purposes.

7. What we do not share with advertising platforms

We do not send the details you type into our intake forms, contact forms, or live chat, such as information about your injury or legal matter, to Google, Meta, TikTok, Reddit, or any other advertising platform.

8. Cookies, pixels, and tracking technologies

The Site uses cookies, pixels, and similar tools. A cookie is a small file stored in your browser. A pixel is a small piece of code that loads when you visit a page and sends information about your visit to the company that provides it. We use Google Tag Manager to load and manage these tools.

The table below lists the third-party tools on the Site and what we use them for.

ProviderWhat we use it forProvider privacy policy
Google Tag ManagerLoads and manages the other tools listed here. It does not build a profile of you.policies.google.com/privacy
Google AnalyticsUnderstanding how visitors use the Site, such as pages viewed and how they found us.policies.google.com/privacy
Google AdsMeasuring ad conversions and showing our ads to past visitors.policies.google.com/privacy
Meta Pixel (Facebook and Instagram)Measuring ad performance, showing our ads to past visitors, and reaching similar audiences.facebook.com/privacy/policy
TikTok PixelMeasuring ad performance, showing our ads to past visitors, and reaching similar audiences.tiktok.com/legal/privacy-policy
Reddit PixelMeasuring ad performance, showing our ads to past visitors, and reaching similar audiences.reddit.com/policies/privacy-policy
IntakerPowers the live chat on the Site so you can reach our intake team.intaker.com
OpenWidget (ChatBot.com)Powers the chat assistant on the Site.openwidget.com
Google reCAPTCHAProtects our forms from spam and automated abuse.policies.google.com/privacy
Google MapsDisplays maps of our office locations.policies.google.com/privacy

These tools may collect the information listed in section 3. If you give us your email address or phone number, a scrambled (hashed) version may be sent to an advertising platform so it can match your visit to an existing account.

Google, Meta, TikTok, and Reddit may combine the information they receive with other data they hold about you and use it under their own privacy policies. You can learn how Google uses information from sites that use its services at  policies.google.com/technologies/partner-sites.

9. Your choices

  • Block or delete cookies in your browser settings. Some parts of the Site may not work as expected if you do.
  • Change your ad settings directly in your Google, Meta, TikTok, or Reddit account.
  • Manage Google ad personalization at  myadcenter.google.com.
  • Install the Google Analytics opt-out browser add-on at  tools.google.com/dlpage/gaoptout.
  • Opt out of interest-based ads from participating companies at  optout.aboutads.info.
  • Reply STOP to any text message to stop receiving texts.
  • Contact us using the information in section 15 to ask us to stop using your information for advertising.

10. Residents of certain states

Some state privacy laws, including California’s, may treat sharing information through advertising pixels as a “sale” or “sharing” of personal information, or as targeted advertising. Depending on where you live, you may have the right to know what information we hold about you, to ask us to correct or delete it, and to opt out of its sale or sharing. To make a request, contact us using the information in section 15. We may need to verify your identity before we respond. We will not treat you differently for using these rights.

11. How we protect your information

We use reasonable administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect your information. No method of sending or storing data over the internet is completely secure, so we cannot guarantee the security of information you send us.

12. How long we keep your information

We keep your information as long as we need it for the purposes described in this policy, including to meet legal, ethical, and record-keeping obligations.

13. Children’s privacy

The Site is not directed to children under 13, and we do not knowingly collect personal information from them online. If a parent or guardian is contacting us about a child’s injury, the parent or guardian should submit the inquiry.

14. Changes to this policy

We may update this policy when we add, change, or remove tools on the Site or change how we handle information. We will post the updated version here and change the effective date above.

15. Contact us

If you have questions about this policy or want to make a privacy request, contact us:

  • Phone: 610-510-8883
  • Email: intake@ethenostrofflaw.com
  • Mail: Ethen Ostroff Law, PLLC, 21 E 5th Ave, Suite 102, Conshohocken, PA 19428