Where Negligent Security Incidents Happen

Violent crime feels random when it happens to you. Often it isn’t. It happens in the same kinds of places, for the same reasons, again and again — a garage with no working lights, a gate that has been broken since spring, a club that stopped searching people at the door because the line moved too slowly.

When a property owner sees that risk building and does nothing, the law may hold them accountable. A negligent security lawyer looks at where you were hurt and asks a simple question: was this crime foreseeable, and did the owner take reasonable steps to prevent it? Below is where these cases most often arise in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, and what tends to matter in each setting.

Find out if you have a case

Free and confidential. No fee unless we win.

Disclaimer: By submitting the form above and checking the consent box, you agree to our conditions and privacy policy and permit Ethen Ostroff Law to contact you via text messages, phone calls (including automated calls). Standard message rates may apply.

Find Out If You Have a Case For FREE Below No Fee Unless We Win

Disclaimer: By submitting the form above and checking the consent box, you agree to our conditions and privacy policy and permit Ethen Ostroff Law to contact you via text messages, phone calls. Standard message rates may apply.


What Is Considered Negligent Security?

Negligent security is a property owner’s failure to take reasonable precautions against foreseeable crime on their property. It is a branch of premises liability — the same body of law that covers a slip and fall — applied to criminal acts instead of physical hazards like a broken step.

The claim is not that the owner committed the crime. It is that the owner made the crime easy, and knew better. Typical failures look like this:

  • Broken locks, gates, or doors that were reported and never repaired
  • Lighting that was out for weeks or months in lots, stairwells, and walkways
  • Cameras that were decorative, unplugged, or never recording
  • Security guards cut from the budget after a documented crime problem
  • No response to repeated complaints about trespassers or loitering
  • Safety promised in a lease or advertisement that the property never actually delivered

An inadequate security lawsuit turns on foreseeability. If violence at that property was predictable and preventable, the owner may share responsibility for what happened to you.

negligent security lawyer

Where Do Negligent Security Incidents Commonly Happen?

This is the most common setting for negligent security claims. Tenants and their guests are attacked in parking lots, breezeways, stairwells, laundry rooms, and hallways — the common areas the landlord controls, not the individual units.

A negligent security apartment complex case usually starts with what management already knew: prior shootings or robberies on the property, a stack of unanswered complaints, an entry gate stuck open, a security patrol that quietly ended. Pennsylvania and New Jersey treat landlords differently here, which is covered in the legal standards section below.

We cover this setting in depth in our guide on suing an apartment complex after a shooting.

Garages and lots are isolated, poorly lit, full of blind corners, and often unmonitored after dark. They are where a large share of negligent security parking lot cases begin — carjackings, robberies, assaults, and abductions.

Pennsylvania courts have taken these seriously for decades. In Murphy v. Penn Fruit Co., 274 Pa. Super. 427 (1980), a store’s prior notice of crimes occurring behind its parking lot supported liability when a customer was stabbed there. What usually matters is the lighting, the camera coverage, whether anyone patrolled, and whether the business already knew crime was happening on the edges of its property.

Hotels invite strangers to sleep behind doors they do not control, which is why innkeepers have long been held to a heightened duty toward their guests. A negligent security hotel case often involves key card systems that were never reprogrammed, exterior doors propped open, a staff member who let someone into a room, no camera coverage in corridors or stairwells, or a property with a documented history of assaults and trafficking that management treated as routine.

Extended-stay and budget properties with known drug or trafficking activity come up often. So does the gap between what the booking site promised about safety and what the property actually did.

Alcohol, crowds, and late hours are a predictable combination, and venues know it. A negligent security bar or nightclub case typically involves no bag or weapon screening at the door, too few staff for the crowd, bouncers who used excessive force or none at all, an ignored history of fights, or an unlit lot where patrons walk to their cars at 2am.

There is often a second claim here. Both states have dram shop laws covering the negligent service of alcohol. In New Jersey, the Licensed Alcoholic Beverage Server Fair Liability Act, N.J.S.A. 2A:22A-5, allows a claim where a server served someone visibly intoxicated and that service foreseeably caused the injury. Pennsylvania’s provision, 47 P.S. § 4-497, addresses harm inflicted off the licensed premises by a customer served while visibly intoxicated. For an assault inside the bar in Pennsylvania, the claim usually runs through ordinary negligence and the venue’s duty to its patrons rather than the dram shop statute. Which theory applies depends on where the harm happened and who caused it.

Malls, big-box stores, and strip centers invite the public in for profit, and that invitation carries a duty. A negligent security shopping mall case often involves an unpatrolled parking deck, entrances with no camera coverage, security staffing cut during the hours crime actually occurs, or an owner who tracked incidents internally and never acted on them.

One point worth knowing: a Pennsylvania court has made clear that a claim does not require nearly identical crimes to have happened at the exact spot where you were hurt. Notice of prior criminal activity on the premises can be enough to put the question to a jury. Property owners routinely argue the opposite, so it matters.

A negligent security college campus case can involve dorms with propped-open exterior doors, broken card readers, unlit paths between buildings, parking garages with no attendant, or a school that failed to warn students about an ongoing threat.

Campuses generate unusually good evidence. Under the federal Clery Act, 20 U.S.C. § 1092(f), colleges receiving federal student aid must publish an annual security report with three years of crime statistics, keep a daily crime log open to the public, and issue timely warnings about ongoing threats. That is a documented record of what the school knew and when. The law is named for Jeanne Clery, a student killed in her residence hall at Lehigh University here in Pennsylvania in 1986.

The same principles reach well beyond the six settings above:

  • Gas stations and convenience stores, especially those open overnight
  • ATM vestibules and bank parking areas
  • Office buildings with unstaffed lobbies or unsecured garages
  • Hospitals, medical office parks, and their visitor lots
  • Concert venues, stadiums, festivals, and event spaces
  • Transit stations, park-and-rides, and airport garages
  • Self-storage facilities and gyms with 24-hour keycard access
  • Restaurants, casinos, and entertainment complexes

If a property invited you in and had reason to expect violence, the setting matters less than what the owner knew.

Why Where You Were Hurt Changes the Legal Standard

Pennsylvania: businesses are held to a broader duty than landlords

For businesses open to the public, Pennsylvania follows Section 344 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts, adopted in Moran v. Valley Forge Drive-In Theater, 431 Pa. 432 (1968). A property owner who holds land open to the public for business purposes can be liable for physical harm caused by the intentionally harmful acts of third persons, where reasonable care could have discovered the risk and prevented or warned of it. Where the owner should reasonably anticipate criminal conduct, the duty to take precautions follows. That covers stores, malls, hotels, bars, restaurants, and parking areas serving them.

Landlords are treated differently. Under Feld v. Merriam, 506 Pa. 383 (1984), simply being a landlord does not by itself create a duty to provide a security program. But once a landlord provides one, it must be maintained with reasonable care — liability can follow where the measures were unreasonable, increased the risk, or were allowed to stop working.

So in Pennsylvania, the same broken gate can support two different arguments depending on whether it guards a shopping center or an apartment complex.

New Jersey: a broader duty across the board

New Jersey is more favorable to injured people in both settings. In Trentacost v. Brussel, 82 N.J. 214 (1980), the state Supreme Court held a landlord liable for a criminal assault in a common area of a building in a high-crime neighborhood where the front door had no lock. New Jersey courts have since described the modern view plainly: landlords have a duty to protect tenants and patrons from the foreseeable criminal acts of third parties on their premises. See Clohesy v. Food Circus Supermarkets, 149 N.J. 496 (1997), which applied that principle to a supermarket parking lot.

Ethen Ostroff Law is licensed in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. If your case falls outside those two states, reach out anyway — we work with trusted referral partners nationwide and will help you get to the right attorney. Justice For All means we do not turn people away at the state line.

Can I Sue a Property Owner for Inadequate Security?

In many cases, yes. Property owner liability for crime is a recognized claim in both Pennsylvania and New Jersey, and it does not depend on the criminal case.

Two things surprise people most often:

  • You do not need the attacker identified, arrested, or convicted. Your civil case is about the property owner’s conduct, not the attacker’s.
  • You do not have to be a tenant or a paying customer. Guests, visitors, employees, and delivery drivers have all brought these claims.

Defendants can include the property owner, the management company, a separate security contractor, a parent company, and sometimes the business that leased the space. Sorting out who actually controlled security is part of what a negligent security attorney does early.

What Must I Prove in a Negligent Security Case?

Four elements, in plain terms:

  1. Duty — the owner owed you a legal obligation of reasonable care, which depends on the setting and the state, as above.
  2. Foreseeability and breach — violence was predictable there, and the owner’s response fell short of reasonable.
  3. Causation — the security failure is what allowed the crime to reach you.
  4. Damages — you suffered real harm: injuries, bills, lost income, trauma, or the loss of a family member.

Foreseeability is where these cases are won and lost, and it is proved with records the property controls:

  • Police call histories and incident reports for the address and surrounding blocks
  • The owner’s internal incident logs, guard post orders, and security vendor contracts
  • Tenant or customer complaints, maintenance tickets, and unfilled work orders
  • Surveillance footage from the property and neighboring businesses
  • Leases, booking pages, and advertising that promised security
  • Clery Act reports and daily crime logs, for campus cases
  • Testimony from a security expert on what a reasonable property would have done

Footage is the urgent piece. Many systems overwrite themselves within two to four weeks. One of the first steps in these cases is a preservation letter demanding the property hold video, logs, and records before they are gone.

What Compensation Is Available in a Negligent Security Lawsuit?

Depending on the facts, you may be entitled to recover:

  • Emergency care, surgeries, future treatment, therapy, and long-term care
  • Lost wages and lost future earning capacity
  • Assistive devices, home modifications, and relocation costs when it is not safe to return
  • Pain and suffering, emotional distress, and PTSD
  • Scarring, disfigurement, and permanent disability
  • Loss of the enjoyment of life

If a crime was fatal, surviving family members may pursue a wrongful death claim covering funeral costs, lost financial support, and the loss of the person’s companionship and guidance. Pennsylvania also allows a companion survival action on behalf of the estate.

Both states use modified comparative negligence — 42 Pa.C.S. § 7102 in Pennsylvania and N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1 in New Jersey. Your recovery is reduced by your share of the fault, and you are generally barred if your share exceeds the defendants’ combined share. Property owners lean on this hard, which is one reason not to give a recorded statement to their insurer before speaking with an attorney. No lawyer can promise an outcome, and every case turns on its own facts.

How Long Do You Have to File?

Generally two years from the date of injury in both states — 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524 in Pennsylvania and N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2 in New Jersey. Wrongful death claims generally run two years from the date of death under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2) and N.J.S.A. 2A:31-3. Deadlines for injured minors are typically paused until they turn 18.

Public property is the trap. If the incident happened at a housing authority property, a state university, a transit station, or another government-run location, much shorter notice deadlines apply. Pennsylvania generally requires written notice to the government unit within six months under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5522(a). New Jersey generally requires a notice of claim within 90 days under N.J.S.A. 59:8-8, and missing it can bar the claim entirely. If a public entity might be involved, talk to someone immediately.

When to Talk to a Negligent Security Lawyer

Sooner than feels natural. Not because anyone should be rushing you, but because the evidence has a clock on it. Video gets overwritten. Broken lights get replaced the week after an incident. Staff turn over. Complaint files get purged.

It is worth a conversation if any of this sounds familiar:

  • You were attacked at a property that had a known crime problem
  • Something was broken — a gate, a lock, a light, a camera — and had been for a while
  • You or others had complained before and nothing changed
  • Security was advertised or promised and was not actually there
  • Guards or patrols had recently been cut back

You do not need to know whether you have a case. That is our job to figure out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Negligent security is a property owner’s failure to take reasonable precautions against foreseeable crime on their property. It is a form of premises liability applied to criminal acts rather than physical hazards. Common examples include broken locks and gates, burned-out lighting, cameras that were never recording, guards cut from the budget after a known crime problem, and complaints management ignored.

Most often at apartment complexes, parking lots and garages, hotels and motels, bars and nightclubs, shopping malls and retail properties, and college campuses. They also arise at gas stations, ATMs, office buildings, hospitals, event venues, transit stations, and gyms. What connects them is a property that invited people in and had reason to expect violence.

In many cases, yes. Property owner liability for crime is recognized in both Pennsylvania and New Jersey. You do not need the attacker identified or convicted, and you do not have to be a tenant or paying customer — guests, visitors, and employees can bring these claims. The standard varies by setting: Pennsylvania holds businesses open to the public to a broader duty than landlords, while New Jersey applies a broad duty in both settings.

Four things: that the owner owed you a duty of reasonable care, that crime there was foreseeable and the owner’s response fell short, that the security failure allowed the crime to reach you, and that you suffered real harm. Foreseeability is the contested element, and it is proved with police call histories, the owner’s internal incident logs, unanswered complaints, maintenance records, and surveillance footage.

You could recover economic and non-economic damages — medical care, future treatment, lost wages, lost earning capacity, pain and suffering, emotional distress, scarring, and permanent disability. Families may pursue a wrongful death claim after a fatal incident. Recovery is reduced by your share of fault under both states’ comparative negligence rules, amounts vary widely, and no result can be guaranteed.

Talk to a Negligent Security Attorney in Pennsylvania or New Jersey

Being attacked somewhere you had every reason to feel safe changes how you move through the world. You did not cause it, and you should not have to carry the cost of someone else’s negligence alone.

Ethen Ostroff Law is Pennsylvania’s Injury Firm, serving clients across Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We investigate what a property knew, what it promised, and what it failed to do — and we hold owners, management companies, and security contractors accountable for it. Our consultations are always free, and you pay nothing unless we recover for you.

Call Ethen Ostroff Law today for a free, confidential consultation, or reach out through EOL.law. One conversation costs you nothing and can tell you where you stand.

Justice For All — that’s our promise at Ethen Ostroff Law.

His career began in public service as a Surveillance Officer in Maricopa County, where he gained firsthand experience in high-stakes decision-making and developed a deep sense of discipline and accountability. He later served as Chief Operating Officer of a fast-growing law firm, driving efficiency, revenue growth, and team development. Today, Ryan focuses on helping law firms reach their full potential by aligning people, processes, and long-term vision. A strategic thinker and empowering leader, Ryan is passionate about developing others and guiding organizations through meaningful, lasting growth.

Success

We received your information. We’ll be in touch soon.

Ethen Ostroff Law, PLLC Privacy Policy

Effective Date: 10/15/2026

Ethen Ostroff Law, PLLC (“EOL,” “we,” “us,” or “our”) respects your privacy. If you are reaching out to us after an injury, we know you may be sharing personal details during a hard time. This Privacy Policy explains what information we collect when you visit ethenostrofflaw.com (the “Site”), how we use it, who we share it with, and the choices you have.

This Privacy Policy works together with our Terms of Use. By using the Site, you agree to the practices described here. If you do not agree, please do not use the Site.

1. A note about confidentiality

Visiting the Site, submitting a form, chatting with us online, or sending us an email does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship begins only when you and EOL sign a written Retainer Agreement. Until then, information you send us is not protected by attorney-client privilege and is not considered confidential. Please do not send sensitive details about your matter until we have spoken with you.

2. Information you give us

When you request a free consultation, fill out a form, use our live chat, call, text, or email us, you may give us:

  • Your name, phone number, email address, and mailing address
  • The state where you live or where your injury happened
  • Details about your injury, accident, employer, or legal matter
  • Anything else you choose to include in a message or chat

3. Information collected automatically

When you visit the Site, we and the third-party tools described in section 8 may automatically collect:

  • Your IP address and general location
  • Browser type, device type, and operating system
  • Pages you visit, how long you stay, and the page or ad that referred you
  • Actions you take, such as clicking a button or submitting a form
  • Cookie IDs and similar identifiers

4. How we use your information

  • To respond to you and evaluate whether we may be able to help with your matter
  • To contact you by phone, text, or email about your inquiry or case
  • To understand how people use the Site and improve it
  • To measure how well our advertising performs
  • To show our ads to people who have visited the Site and to reach new people who may need our help
  • To protect the Site from spam and abuse
  • To comply with legal and ethical obligations

5. How we share your information

We may share your information with:

  • Service providers who help us run the Site, our chat tools, our phone and text systems, and our case intake process. They may use your information only to provide services to us.
  • Advertising and analytics partners through the cookies and pixels described in section 8.
  • Other law firms and attorneys. If your matter is outside our practice or the states we serve, we may refer you to another firm. EOL may also refer or sell inquiries that come through our marketing, including certain campaigns run with third-party marketing companies.
  • Legal and safety recipients when required by law, court order, or professional rules, or to protect our rights or the safety of others.
  • A successor in connection with a merger, sale, or transfer of our practice, where permitted by professional rules.

6. Text messages

If you opt in to text messages, you may receive messages about your inquiry or case. Message frequency varies, and message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP at any time to opt out, or HELP for help. Mobile phone numbers and text message opt-in consent will not be shared with third parties or affiliates for their own marketing purposes.

7. What we do not share with advertising platforms

We do not send the details you type into our intake forms, contact forms, or live chat, such as information about your injury or legal matter, to Google, Meta, TikTok, Reddit, or any other advertising platform.

8. Cookies, pixels, and tracking technologies

The Site uses cookies, pixels, and similar tools. A cookie is a small file stored in your browser. A pixel is a small piece of code that loads when you visit a page and sends information about your visit to the company that provides it. We use Google Tag Manager to load and manage these tools.

The table below lists the third-party tools on the Site and what we use them for.

ProviderWhat we use it forProvider privacy policy
Google Tag ManagerLoads and manages the other tools listed here. It does not build a profile of you.policies.google.com/privacy
Google AnalyticsUnderstanding how visitors use the Site, such as pages viewed and how they found us.policies.google.com/privacy
Google AdsMeasuring ad conversions and showing our ads to past visitors.policies.google.com/privacy
Meta Pixel (Facebook and Instagram)Measuring ad performance, showing our ads to past visitors, and reaching similar audiences.facebook.com/privacy/policy
TikTok PixelMeasuring ad performance, showing our ads to past visitors, and reaching similar audiences.tiktok.com/legal/privacy-policy
Reddit PixelMeasuring ad performance, showing our ads to past visitors, and reaching similar audiences.reddit.com/policies/privacy-policy
IntakerPowers the live chat on the Site so you can reach our intake team.intaker.com
OpenWidget (ChatBot.com)Powers the chat assistant on the Site.openwidget.com
Google reCAPTCHAProtects our forms from spam and automated abuse.policies.google.com/privacy
Google MapsDisplays maps of our office locations.policies.google.com/privacy

These tools may collect the information listed in section 3. If you give us your email address or phone number, a scrambled (hashed) version may be sent to an advertising platform so it can match your visit to an existing account.

Google, Meta, TikTok, and Reddit may combine the information they receive with other data they hold about you and use it under their own privacy policies. You can learn how Google uses information from sites that use its services at  policies.google.com/technologies/partner-sites.

9. Your choices

  • Block or delete cookies in your browser settings. Some parts of the Site may not work as expected if you do.
  • Change your ad settings directly in your Google, Meta, TikTok, or Reddit account.
  • Manage Google ad personalization at  myadcenter.google.com.
  • Install the Google Analytics opt-out browser add-on at  tools.google.com/dlpage/gaoptout.
  • Opt out of interest-based ads from participating companies at  optout.aboutads.info.
  • Reply STOP to any text message to stop receiving texts.
  • Contact us using the information in section 15 to ask us to stop using your information for advertising.

10. Residents of certain states

Some state privacy laws, including California’s, may treat sharing information through advertising pixels as a “sale” or “sharing” of personal information, or as targeted advertising. Depending on where you live, you may have the right to know what information we hold about you, to ask us to correct or delete it, and to opt out of its sale or sharing. To make a request, contact us using the information in section 15. We may need to verify your identity before we respond. We will not treat you differently for using these rights.

11. How we protect your information

We use reasonable administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect your information. No method of sending or storing data over the internet is completely secure, so we cannot guarantee the security of information you send us.

12. How long we keep your information

We keep your information as long as we need it for the purposes described in this policy, including to meet legal, ethical, and record-keeping obligations.

13. Children’s privacy

The Site is not directed to children under 13, and we do not knowingly collect personal information from them online. If a parent or guardian is contacting us about a child’s injury, the parent or guardian should submit the inquiry.

14. Changes to this policy

We may update this policy when we add, change, or remove tools on the Site or change how we handle information. We will post the updated version here and change the effective date above.

15. Contact us

If you have questions about this policy or want to make a privacy request, contact us:

  • Phone: 610-510-8883
  • Email: intake@ethenostrofflaw.com
  • Mail: Ethen Ostroff Law, PLLC, 21 E 5th Ave, Suite 102, Conshohocken, PA 19428